Sugar cookies - it's a Christmas baking staple. I have always wanted to bake eggless sugar cookies. It has been in my "to-bake" list for years now.
A couple of months back when I was browsing my favorite recipe website I was excited to find a sugar cookie recipe without eggs. I bookmarked it dutifully to bake it a little ahead of the Winter Holidays to test bake and sort of completely forgot about it.
Then one day my kids insisted that they wanted to bake with me and I couldn't find any fun recipe other than this eggless sugar cookie recipe. Once I told them the idea that they get to decorate it with colored sprinkles they jumped in joy.
So here on-wards when it's Christmastime and you don't have to wonder how to make sugar cookies without eggs because here is your solution. Tried and tasted tested by children as well as adults, a very easy-to-bake no egg sugar cookies.
Recipe
Eggless Sugar Cookies
Ingredients
- 1 cup unsalted butter softened
- ¾ cup white sugar
- 1 tablespoon white vinegar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- As needed colored sugar
Instructions
- In a large bowl cream together the butter and sugar until light and fluffy. Beat in the vinegar and vanilla extract.
- In another bowl, combine the flour and baking soda. Incorporate this into the creamed sugar mixture and mix well.
- Scoop out a tablespoon of dough for each cookie, roll it into a ball, and flatten into ¼ inch thickness; sprinkle with colored sugar and place 2 inches apart (See My Notes)
- Bake in an oven preheated at 350F/180C in a greased pan for 8 to 10 minutes or until the edges are lightly browned. Transfer the pan to a wire rack and let the cookies cool down for 2-3 minutes before removing them from the pan. Store it in air-tight containers once it's cooled completely.
My Notes
- I felt the batter was a bit loose...not quite stiff. So decided to put it in the fridge for a while. Otherwise, the cookies would spread too much. This was not mentioned in the original recipe, but I did it because the dough consistency did not feel right. Initially, I stored the dough in the fridge for a while (20 mins maybe) and then rolled, flattened, and sprinkled the sugar. By the time I started rolling and flattening, I felt it was becoming sticky again. So put the cookie sheet in the fridge again for another 10 minutes to harden up a little. The cookies spread out perfectly and beautifully.
- I was also skeptical about vinegar in the recipe and wondered how it would taste. When I tasted the dough, I noticed a hint of sourness, but I couldn't taste it in the cookies. So trust me, go ahead and bake these cookies.
Taste & Texture
Nutrition
nat says
i loved these they turned out like any sugar cookie with eggs
Madhuram says
Thanks, Nat.
Kaela says
It's about time I left a review because I have made these many times and sent the recipe out several times to those who have asked for it 🙂 these are my go-to treats for my egg-allergic daughters and I bring them to many events! I make them with the colored sugar a lot but have also used jimmy sprinkles or cinnamon sugar to top them. They come together quickly, they look good, and most important of all they are delicious.
Madhuram says
Thank you very much for taking the time to leave your kind feedback, Kaela.
Inderani says
Has anyone used this recipe to make cut out cookies? My son is allergic to eggs and want to make Christmas cookies tonight with him. I like the egg free pancake recipe from this site, it is my go to pancake recipe that I have been using for years so I thought I would try the cookie recipe.
Jennifer says
Recipe needs salt but otherwise a goo egg free recipe
Rhonda says
I used this as the base for raisin filled cookies. It was perfect. Definitely let the dough rest in the fridge for 20 minutes or so. Rolled out beautifully. I, also, replaced half the sugar with confectioner's monks fruit. Yummy.
Madhuram says
Thank you for the feedback, Rhonda.
Rosanna says
just made these cookies. why is my dough so crumbly? I could hardly roll out the balls because it was fall apart..super dry mixture.
Kaela says
I have had this happen once or twice with the recipe and I suspected it was because I didn't whip the butter long enough
Betty says
I went hunting for an eggless recipe and gave this a shot. I am out of eggs, out of milk, and out of butter. I substituted the butter in this recipe for 1/2 cup shortening and 1/2 cup spreadable cream cheese. When I creamed the sugar it seemed too wet so I added 1/4 cup sugar making this recipe a whole cup of sugar. I was also out of vinegar so I substituted lemon juice for the vinegar. I added funfetti baking chips and put bee pollen on top for more of that sprinkles effect (I am also out of sprinkles). I might post somewhere as my Out of Everything Sugar Cookie Recipe because they turned out great!!!
Madhuram says
Wow! It's great to know that the cookies turned out great even after all these alterations. Thank you for sharing your experience.
Josephine says
What would you recommend for measurements for two big cookies ? I want to do a cookie cake that is the number 11 about 8inch. Thank you
Madhuram says
I'm unable to give you any concrete suggestions because I have not tried such a thing. Maybe you can make a batch of dough with the above measurements and see if you are able to get either 11 or 8 and make another batch if necessary.
Angela G says
This is a great recipe! I had to add an extra 1/2 cup of butter to my dough because it was dry and crumbly. This may be because I live at high altitude and low humidity. Other than that, they are perfect. I rolled mine in a cinnamon sugar mixture 🙂
Madhuram says
Thank you, Angela.
Jules says
Such a smart way for egg substitute. Not going to lie I was very skeptical at first but it turned out great. The dough was good too! I added a few twists to mine; 1) lemon extract to make a fresh lemonade type cookie and 2) a cinnamon sugar mixture that i rolled my dough balls to get a snickerdoodle-esque cookie!
Madhuram says
Thank you for the feedback, Jules. Those are some awesome substitutions!
Gerald Caucci says
I'm 72..complete rookie with bakin cookie!!
but these things are easy and you can put stuff in em, or on em, or both, if ya want!
If I CAN DO IT...YOU CAN DO IT..testimonial from a cookie rookie..thanks for the recipe..gonna teach the magic to the grandkids..
Popular papa!!
Cookie Rookie Popular Papa..
I know, right??!!✊
Madhuram says
Your energy is oozing out in the comment and very infectious, Gerald. Love it! Thank you for taking the time to leave your valuable feedback.
Adam says
I have never commented on a recipe before, but I can’t not thank you for this! 🙂 my partner has an egg allergy so I am always trying to find new things to bake so he can snack with everyone. The first time I made these, WOW! We were hooked! Not only he and I but family and friends cannot get enough as well. I’ve made them at least 15 times now. It’s a new staple. The only adjustment I made was rolling the dough balls in granulated sugar instead of using larger colored sugar. I then squash the dough a bit and press the tops with a fork like peanut butter cookies. Seems to work well and gives it a fun finished look. Again, THANK YOU!
Madhuram says
Thank you very much, Adam, for taking the time to leave detailed feedback. I sincerely appreciate this lovely gesture.
Liv says
I didn’t have eggs and these were great. Taste is an 8/10 I would’ve preferred with more vanilla and maybe a little brown sugar. Texture 7.5/10 slightly dry but very soft and chewy. Overall will bake again very simple. Cookies are 8/10
Madhuram says
Thank you, Liv.
Frankie Giles says
Thank you for sharing recipe. My granddaughter has an egg allergy and these are so good. I am making a second batch this morning for St., Patrick's Day..
Madhuram says
Thank you for the feedback, Frankie.
Cassandra says
I’m surprised—these are really good! It’s just me, so I 1/8 the recipe, enough for four nice, big cookies. I didn’t have any vinegar, but they were fine without it. I’ll definitely make these again!
Madhuram says
Wow! Thank you for the feedback, Cassandra.
Betty says
I made these using Splenda blend sugar and added 1/2 tsp extra vanilla. I rolled them out in powdered sugar to 1/4in and used heart shape cookie cutter for Valentine’s cookies. I did place the cookies on cookie sheet in refrigerated for about an hour before baking.They are delicious!!!
Madhuram says
Thank you very much for the feedback, Betty. Glad to know that it works with Splenda too.
Aida C. says
I decided to bake these with my little girl. Substituted coconut oil for the butter (we were out). We rolled balls thinking they would spread out but they didn't. Instead we got something we call snowballs. They were semi- soft on the outside and soft inside. Our second batch we decided to smash with a fork and dust with colored sugar baked an extra 5 min and they were amazingly crunchy and delicious.
Madhuram says
That's interesting, Aida. Thank you for the feedback.
Lilith C says
I made these and they were amazing taste wise! However I ignored that I should let the batter rest and used a 3tbs scoop to put the cookies on the pan, And they ended up the size of my fist- But that was an issue on my end, But overall this is a great cookie recipe!
Madhuram says
Thank you for trying the recipe and for the feedback, Lilith.
Nunya says
Terrible recipe did not turn out and tasted terrible
Madhuram says
I'm sorry that you couldn't get it right unlike many other readers. Please let me know what went wrong and maybe we can figure it out.
Jennifer says
These were great. I used Bob’s Red Mill All Purpose Gluten Free Flour. I also refrigerated for a couple hours. These turned out great—the regular cookies with sugar sprinkles as described were better—but we were also able to do a few Christmas cutouts. Will definitely use this recipe again for holidays!
Madhuram says
Thank you very much, Jennifer.
Alexia Severson says
Thank you so much for sharing you're recipe . I would have used vanilla extract but I was out. However these turned out so delicious .
Madhuram says
You're welcome, Alexia.
kitti says
great recipe. substituted coconut oil for butter to make these vegan. turned out great. highly recommend.
Madhuram says
Wow! I didn't know that this recipe would work with coconut oil too. Thank you very much for the feedback, Kitti.
Karen E says
These were amazing! We just made our second batch so Santa could have cookies too. My great granddaughter has an egg and dairy allergy. We used Smart Balance Olive Oil blend. We were able to make our Christmas cutout cookies. Everyone enjoyed them very much. Thank you for this recipe!
Madhuram says
You're very welcome, Karen. I'm glad that your great-granddaughter got to enjoy these cookies.
Rebecca Murphy says
Thank you so much for sharing this recipe I made the first batch just like the recipe and the dough was perfect but I put them in the fridge just in case they turned out great my kids all loved them so I made a second batch and added coconut flavoring to them they also turned out great. Santa is going to love these cookie thank you again for sharing. I loved making these with my kids. I don't know what the people that wrote bad reviews did wrong but these are awesome cookies and taste nothing like flour. So for those that read the reviews before they try something new let me give you some advice it's better to try something for yourself and see how it turns out and use your own judgement than to listen to others because not everyone can cook and some just want to be mean. Against n thank you for the memories that I got to make with this recipe.
Madhuram says
Dear Rebecca, thank you very much for your kind words. I sincerely appreciate your feedback and your time. Happy Holidays!
Kate says
I've been using this recipe the past few years for my Christmas cookies. I put a bit of flour on my counter and roll out the dough for cutout cookie, sprinkle with sugar and bake. Perfect! My family (and one with an egg allergy) love these cookies! Thank you Madhuram!
Madhuram says
You're very welcome, Kate.
Birgitt says
Oh my goodness, can't believe how delicious these cookies are, made them for a family member, but ate almost all before the get together. I didn't have unsalted butter, so used what I had, The dough is super soft, but once scooped out and flattened slightly with a glass, baked up perfectly, did not even need to refrigerate first. Thank you for sharing this recipe!
Madhuram says
Your excitement is infectious, Birgitt! Thank you very much for the feedback.
Kari says
No no no no noooo. I followed the directions to the letter. I even had an oven thermometer make sure the temp was accurate. And Wow. Vinegar cookies. Really. The acid was really powerful.3/4 of a cup of vinegar is waayyy too much. Holy yuck.
Madhuram says
What? 3/4th cup of vinegar? Please check the recipe, it says just 1 tablespoon of vinegar.
Carrie Stanley says
The taste was fine, but I needed to add an 1/8c more flour, and I’d have added a pinch of salt next time. You can also use a third less butter; these are a little greasy but fine for a child with allergies!
Chris says
I just made these because my toddler has an egg allergy. They turned out amazing! I did 1 cup of sugar and also added a splash of almond for flavor. We also frosted half of them. They turned out great! Thank you for the recipe. I’ll be using this for years to come.
Madhuram says
You're very welcome, Chris.
Jerry Caucci says
TESTIMONIAL!!
I can't bake worth crap...really...I cook...i'm italian, it's inbred..anyways...lookin for sweets (I ain't supposed to eat!!)..found this recipe..gotta tell ya, these cookies are amazing..once I got down "baking terminology", these suckers made themselves!! All I did was follow the direc tions...first time in 71 years I've ever baked anything that came out this good!! I LUV WHOMEVER/WHOEVER POSTED THIS RECIPIE...IT'S GONNA BE A WEEKLY STAPLE.(don't tell my Doc!!)
now all I gotta do is find a good "butter frosting" recipe, and screw the bakery isle from now on!!✊
Grazi for the cookies!!
Madhuram says
Wow! Thank you very much, Jerry! You have made my day with your awesome feedback!
Claudia says
Can I cut these into shapes with cutters for my grandson to decorate?
Madhuram says
I have not tried shapes with this recipe, Claudia.
Samantha says
Amazing recipe! It’s important to chill all sugar cookie doughs for roughly an hour to help refirm the buttery dough. Be sure to follow the directions exactly and make sure your vinegar is WELL incorporated before adding flour mixture. Hands down he best vegan/allergy friendly recipe I have found.
Madhuram says
Thank you very much, Samantha.
Stormie says
I have young neighbors who have a little one who is allergic to eggs, so this recipe was perfect. I could not find my vanilla, so I used almond extract instead. The cookies were fantastic. Next time I make them I will use vanilla. Thank you for sharing your recipe.
Madhuram says
You're very welcome, Stormie. Actually I want to try it with almond extract the next time. You have planted that idea in my brain 🙂
Sally says
I love this so much great job
Madhuram says
Thank you, Sally.
Raquel says
I kept thinking about 'why the vinegar?' until I remembered that there are recipes that use cream of tartar. That is the cleverest substitute EVER! I'm about to make them. Wish me luck.
Madhuram says
All the best, Raquel!
Olivia Griffith says
Holy God. I wish I could truly express how awful these cookies are. They taste like flour and have zero flavor. I even added extra vanilla and sugar. Would NEVER make these again
Madhuram says
It's unfortunate that you couldn't get the recipe right, Olivia.
Crystal Watson says
yes!
Stormie says
The cookies I made with this recipe were fantastic. I'm surprised at your experience with the recipe.
Madhuram says
Thank you, Stormie.
Savannah says
These are awful. They taste like flour and don't take anywhere near 10 minutes to cook. I followed the recipe exactly and I even used the tips. Will not be making again.
Madhuram says
It's unfortunate that you didn't get it right, Savannah. Please note that many of the readers have got it right.
Margaret Re says
I completely followed recipe. Would not change a thing...perfect cookie! Thanks for sharing.
Madhuram says
You're welcome, Margaret Re.
Christie Pancake says
These turned out great! My very picky daughter said, “Don’t tell the eggs…these are better!”
Madhuram says
Awww...thank you very much, Christie.
Brianne says
Great recipe! I used a half teaspoon more vanilla and rolled the balls in cinnamon sugar before baking. I did not find the dough loose or needed to be chilled first. They took about 12 minutes for me but are fantastic! Soft, chewy, quick and easy. Thanks for sharing!
Madhuram says
You're welcome, Brianne.
Olivia says
I made these cookies for my friends and family becasue they are vegatarian and/or have egg allergies so this was the perfect recipe. I think i cut them too thin though so they turned more crispy, but still tasted delicious. Just remember not to cut them too thin!
Madhuram says
Thanks for the feedback, Olivia.
Faye L Palmer says
Thank you!
Madhuram says
You're welcome.
Faye L Palmer says
Yes, worked out great. I got a perfect consistency for roll or drop cookies. Did drop cookies and they baked up very nicely, even with adding a little almond extract.
Madhuram says
Thank you for the feedback.
Chesa says
Since we had decided to go low carb 2yrs ago, I have been searching for a decent sugar cookie recipe. OMG! I found the perfect recipe! Thank you so much for sharing. Note: I did not have any vinegar so I used a bit of lemon juice instead. Thank you again for allowing your recipe become my favorite cookie recipe!
Madhuram says
Awww...thank you so much, Chesa.
JD says
These are really, really good! Can't taste the vinegar at all. Definitely will be my go-to cookie recipe from now on, and yes I'm eating one as I type this but I better leave some for the kids when they get home from school! 🙂
Madhuram says
Thank you very much, JD.
Leigh Byer says
These cookies are delicious. Very surprised at the taste! I created the recipe as required and added chocolate chips. What a hit! I just made up my fourth batch and froze them into little decorated balls with colored sugars and stars. All I have to do is pull out what I need and bake! Highly successful when baked on parchment paper and depending on the size of the balls, you may need to add a couple minutes to the baking time. Yay for my 2 yr. Old grandson. With egg allergies. We got this!
Madhuram says
That's awesome, Leigh. I wouldn't have thought of adding chocolate chips to this cookie recipe. Thank you for the tip.
Carolyn says
Any cookie dough that you will be 'rolling out' should always be chilled at least 30 minutes. Just take out enough for one sheet at a time.
Madhuram says
Thank you, Carolyn.
Jada says
are you suppose to put it in the refrigerator?
Madhuram says
Depending upon the consistency of the dough you can decide it, Jada.